Digital Kitsch Lies To The User & Presumes They’re Stupid

“Look at the new elec­tronic books, par­tic­u­larly those on Apple’s amaz­ing iPad: a book is pre­sented as a repro­duc­tion of the tra­di­tional stack of bound pieces of paper. Going from one page to the next is accom­pa­nied by an ani­ma­tion of it being turned, even with the sound of paper being rus­tled. While you keep thumb­ing pages, how­ever, the stack stays equally thick on either side, turn­ing the metaphor into a lie, into dig­i­tal kitsch. It feels wrong and it is wrong. Metaphors are use­ful because we do not really want to know what goes on in the dig­i­tal maze under the bon­net that the oper­at­ing sys­tem hides. Super­flu­ous visual noise doesn’t make the read­ing any eas­ier, it just pre­sumes that we’re too stu­pid to notice the dif­fer­ence between a stack of glued paper and a battery-driven piece of plas­tic. If peo­ple really wanted to emu­late the whole phys­i­cal expe­ri­ence, why not give us the musty smell of old books, the scent of print­ing ink?”

Legendary typographer/typophile and design master Erik Spiekermann describes his woes with Apple’s recent trend—particularly with Mac OS X Lion and Mountain Lion—towards skeuomorphic UI and digital kitsch. And he’s right. He’s absolutely right. Read more on his article From Metaphor to Maturity.





Comments

2 Comments so far. Leave a comment below.
  1. I’m more convinced by this: http://tobiasahlin.com/blog/skeumorphism-and-storytelling/
    Some examples are plain stupid, but the author still makes a good point.

  2. By the way, remember window shadows? Those are also digital kitch. And they also presume the user is stupid because they do not behave like real-life drop shadows. Here’s how “non-stupid” drop shadows look like: http://www.lri.fr/~dragice/trueshadows/
    But the “stupid” ones are obviously better for usability.

    On a side note, a device that provides the musty smell of old books and the scent of print­ing ink without insane maintenance procedures could be quite popular.

Add Your Comments

Disclaimer
Your email is never published nor shared.
Tips

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <ol> <ul> <li> <strong>

Ready?
Required
Required